Virtual Migrants

art, digital media, performance exploring race, migration, environment, global justice

  • HOME
  • About
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
  • events
    • Migrant Frontiers
  • Exhibitions
    • 90 Degree Citizen
      • Introduction
      • RE-PRESENTING REFUGEES: discussion, performance, exhibition
      • Artists
        • Amang Mardokhy
        • Flora Alexander
        • Iseult Timmermans
        • Maya Chowdhry
        • Mazaher
        • Tracey Zengeni
      • Stephen Welsh (Manchester Museum)
      • 90 Degree Citizen – feedback please!
    • Committed To Represent
      • Introduction
      • Exhibition Photos
      • Gallery: exhibition panels
    • Buy This – installation art
    • Exhibitions history (from the Blog)
  • Performance
    • CONTINENT CHOP CHOP
    • Performance History (from the blog)
  • Blog

  • Breathe!
    • Breathe!
    • Gallery |Breathe! |Photographs
    • Breathe! Information and Resources
    • Breathe! reconnect: recover: reclaim social space
  • Interplay Now
    • Original call out
  • CONTINENT CHOP CHOP
    • The Documentary
    • Gallery Continent Chop Chop – Photographs
    • Remembrance Wall
    • Tour Dates + Tickets
    • NNIMMO BASSEY award-winning African climate activist
    • A5 Flyer for Continent Chop Chop
  • 90 Degree Citizen
    • Feedback please!
    • RE-PRESENTING REFUGEES
    • Artists
      • Amang Mardokhy
      • Flora Alexander
      • Iseult Timmermans
      • Mazaher
      • Tracey Zengeni
  • Centre Cannot Hold
    • About
    • Buy This – installation art
    • Articles (re. climate and race)
      • Article: Climate Change and Race
      • Article: Tolerating Mass Murder
      • Tolerating Mass Murder – Full Paper
  • Other
    • arts
    • climate
    • imperialism
    • linked activity
    • media
    • news
    • project info
    • race
    • refugee
    • reports
    • research

January 12, 2015 by koojchuhan

Condemn murder but DON’T be Charlie!

Condemn murder but DON'T be Charlie!After the recent completely tragic murders I looked at a good number of Charlie Hebdo covers on Google images, and found racist stereotyping to be pretty consistent.  I might add that Muslims seem to be the target of ridicule by Charlie Hebdo more than others are, though thats purely based on the sample from Google images and not a statistical survey.   Sure, Charlie Hebdo does satirise almost everyone, but the way this is done in the case of Muslim people is using repeated images of Muslims that are practically from the colonial era, the equivalent of using gollywogs to depict people of African descent.  If those were to be used to supposedly satirise Africans, most would agree that would be appalling.  Just as if Germans used Jewish stereotypes in the process of satirising Jews, which I do not think would be tolerated either.

In all these cases we are talking also of a historical context of human degradation and abuse of those being satirised in a racist way, which adds a level of pain probably of the kind where salt is aggressively being rubbed into the wound. I won’t labour this argument as there is too much to read about this already, but all this leads to me saying DO condemn murder but DON’T be Charlie!

Other articles that also say condemn murder but don’t be Charlie:

Interestingly, of the following list the most lucid and critical is the first one, by the progressive Jewish Rabbi Michael Lerner of Beyt Tikkun Synagogue in Berkeley – really worth the read:

http://www.filmsforaction.org/articles/mourning-the-parisian-journalists-yet-noticing-the-hypocrisy/

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/politics/2015/01/charlie_hebdo_the_french_satirical_magazine_is_heroic_it_is_also_racist.html

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-01-09/sparrow-we-should-support-charlie-hebdo-not-endorse-it/6007836

http://canadalandshow.com/article/i-am-not-charlie-hebdo

http://www.newstatesman.com/mehdi-hasan/2015/01/muslim-i-m-fed-hypocrisy-free-speech-fundamentalists

[Note: the black and white ‘featured’ image above is a still from the excellent film “Battle Of Algiers”]

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Print
This website mostly features our work from 2013 onwards, for previous work go to: www.virtualmigrants.com

Connect with Us

  • View VirtualMigrants’s profile on Facebook
  • View VirtualMigrants’s profile on Twitter
  • View virtualmigrants’s profile on YouTube

on sale: EXHALE box set of DVD & CD

on sale: EXHALE box set of DVD, audio-CD, booklets – socio-art exploring asylum/refuge

5 years of video, music and digital art engaging with asylum and migration in a new world order, now on sale

Follow this Blog

Enter your email address below and click "FOLLOW" to receive receive notifications of new blog posts by email.

SUBSCRIBE to occasional email news about our projects and events:

Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Facebook

Follow me on Twitter

My Tweets
Fossil Funds Free

Virtual Migrants refuse to take any oil, coal, or gas corporate sponsorship for our cultural work.

  • HOME
  • About
  • events
  • Exhibitions
  • Performance
  • Blog

Pretty Chic Theme By: Pretty Darn Cute Design

 

Loading Comments...